Line your pan: Spray a 9x13-inch baking dish with nonstick cooking spray or line it with parchment paper. Set aside.
Melt the butter: Place butter in a large saucepan over medium-low heat. Stir until completely melted — about 2 minutes. Do not let it brown.
Add marshmallows: Pour in all the marshmallows and stir constantly with a silicone spatula until they melt into a smooth, glossy mixture. This takes about 4-5 minutes. The mixture should be fully combined with no visible lumps of marshmallow remaining. If you see white spots, keep stirring — they'll disappear as long as the heat is low enough.
Remove from heat and fold in cereal: Take the pan off the burner before adding the cereal to avoid over-melting. Pour all 6 cups of Rice Krispies into the marshmallow mixture and stir until every piece is evenly coated. The mixture should be thick but still pliable — if it's already firming up, work quickly.
Press into pan: Transfer the mixture to your prepared dish. Use a buttered spatula or wet hands to press down firmly and evenly. You want about 1/2-inch thickness for clean cutting later. Let cool at room temperature for 30 minutes — do not refrigerate, as it will make the treats too hard.
Cut out shapes: While the treats are still slightly warm (but set enough to hold their shape), use small cookie cutters in monster shapes to press through and lift out your "monsters." For a classic look, you can also slice into squares or rectangles and add eyes with candy eyes pressed gently on top.
Decorate: Press candy eyes onto treats using the flat side against the surface — they'll stick without any extra glue. Add small pieces of M&M or chocolate chip for horns, teeth, or spots. Sprinkle with colorful sprinkles while the treat surface is still slightly tacky so they adhere.
Serve and store: Store in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days. These reheat beautifully — microwave one for 10 seconds if you prefer them gooey.